Coronavirus Scams: Fraud in the Time of a Pandemic

road-sign-464641_1280.jpg

Sadly, but not surprisingly, even with the state of emergency and health crisis affecting the United States and the entire world, scammers throughout the world are not pausing in their work of taking advantage of unsuspecting and vulnerable people. For the period of January 1, 2020 to May 12, 2020, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the U.S. governmental agency tasked with protecting consumers from unfair and deceptive business practices, received 42,151 COVID-19-related complaints, resulting in a total fraud loss of $29.93M. (Those figures are more than double what they were for the period ending April 12, 2020). Additionally, eConsumer.gov, an initiative of the International Consumer Protection and Enforcement Network, received 980 overall of coronavirus-related fraud reports during the same period.

Coronavirus scams run the gamut from fake treatments and fake testing sites to undelivered goods, such as cleaning, medical, and household supplies, to fake charities. The FTC and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have been working together to put a stop to coronavirus treatment scams. These scams usually relate to unapproved and misbranded products that claim to treat or prevent the coronavirus. Products include teas, essential oils, and colloidal silver. The claims of these products have not been backed by any evidence. Moreover, the FDA has stated that there are no currently approved drugs or vaccines to treat or prevent the coronavirus. The FTC has also warned consumers to be suspicious of ads for test kits. So far, there is only one home diagnostic test kit that has been approved by the FDA, but the authorization is limited only to testing at Rutgers Clinical Genomics Laboratory. Similarly, the FTC is cautioning consumers that not every testing site is legitimate. It recommends consulting with a doctor first or getting a referral, if possible. If there is any question as to a site’s legitimacy, the FTC suggests contacting local law enforcement.

Another coronavirus-related scam that the FTC has been watching relates to the economic impact payments, or so-called stimulus payments, issued by the federal government. The FTC is reminding consumers to avoid providing anyone with their personal information and stressing that nothing needs to be done to receive your payment (so long as you filed taxes for 2018 and/or 2019).

Consumers who have knowledge of or suspect that they have been a victim of a coronavirus scam can report it by filing a complaint with the FTC using its online reporting system. Consumers in Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas can also contact the FTC’s Southwest Region Field Office in Dallas at 877-FTC-HELP or by mail to the address posted on its website.

In addition to the FTC, consumers who have been defrauded can file a report with the National Center for Disaster Fraud (NCDF) Hotline at 866-720-5721 or complete the NCDF Disaster Complaint Form, available through the website of the United States Department of Justice. Texas residents can also report disaster scams to the Attorney General of Texas using the web form found on the Consumer Protection page or by calling 1-800-621-0508.

Scams will always exist and scammers will continue to seek susceptible prey. Learn to protect yourself from scammers by following these tips from the FTC:

  • Ignore offers for home vaccinations and test kits;

  • Hang up on robocalls;

  • Watch out for phishing emails and text messages;

  • Research before you donate; and

  • Stay in the know.

Remember that the best way to defeat scammers is to arm yourself with a little knowledge. Remember, it’s just like the NBCUniversal’s public service initiative states: “The More You Know.”

What About Books?

In mid-April, a French court ordered shipping giant Amazon to restrict its sales and deliveries to “essential items.” The order stated that Amazon could only fulfill orders for food, hygiene, and medical items. The court further gave Amazon 24 hours to cease delivery of nonessential items or face steep fines, as much as one million euros per day per infraction. The order was the result of an action filed by a trade union, alleging that Amazon had violated the Labor Code by failing to protect the health and safety of its employees by allowing them to work in crowded, enclosed spaces. As a result of the court order, Amazon shut down its facilities for five days to clean and assess the working environment. Amazon also appealed the order, citing ambiguity in the definition of what constitutes essential as one of the bases of the appeal.

On April 24, the Court of Appeals of Versailles affirmed the lower tribunal’s order. The appellate court also defined specific categories of essential items: hi-tech and information technology; office supplies; pet supplies; health, nutrition, and personal care product; groceries; drinks; and maintenance.

While we applaud the French courts for focusing on the health and safety of workers, we at the Harris County Law Library can’t help but wonder why books were not included among those items deemed essential. Yes, we know that books are not “absolutely necessary,” but they are still extremely important, not in an earth-shattering way, but critical nonetheless. Crucial, too, to a segment of the population that has been overlooked by the digital divide and who have no access to digital versions of print materials. Before the pandemic, print books outsold eBooks. Even in Paris, it seemed as if more commuters were reading print books while commuting on the Paris Metro. Of course, life is much different now. Social distancing and disinfecting have become the norm. Still, we can’t help but feel that books should be considered essential, especially now when physical libraries are closed to the public. Moreover, the French ruling overlooks the obvious health and mental benefits that come from reading books. Reading sharpens the brain and prevents cognitive decline, reduces stress, helps sleep, eases depression, educates and boosts vocabulary, and can even help people live longer. These benefits are extremely important, especially now, when so many people are isolated from their loved ones and friends.

We urge you today (and everyday) to pick up a book, whether a print one or an eBook, and reap the benefits that come from reading the written word. Then, you, too, can see how essential books are.

Rover to the Rescue

On April 27, 2020, Texas Governor Greg Abbott issued Executive Order 18, announcing the reopening of services and businesses beyond those originally considered essential. Subject to certain restrictions listed in the Executive Order and in the full Governor’s Report to Open Texas, certain businesses, such as retail shops, restaurants, movie theaters, shopping malls, golf courses, and museums and libraries will be able to open for up to 25 percent of its listed occupancy. These businesses are still required to follow the minimum standard health protocols recommended by the Texas Department of State Health Services (TDSHS) and should continue to follow social distancing guidelines. The wearing of face masks or other types of face covering is still encouraged. The 66-page report details the multi-phase plan that the governor and the Strike Force to Open Texas have established to reopen Texas and gradually begin the process of returning to work and participating in other activities. One of the actions detailed in the report is to increase and expand availability of COVID-19 testing. According to data available from TDSHS, there were 314,790 cumulative tests performed in the state, as of April 29, 2020. Nevertheless, much of the criticism that Governor Abbott’s reopening plan has been receiving relates to a lack of available testing. Texas has ranked near the bottom in state rankings for per capita testing.

The news may not be all that bleak, however. If a group of scientists in the United Kingdom and Pennsylvania are correct, our canine friends might just be available to help us out in that regard. Researchers at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and the University of Pennsylvania are engaged in projects to train dogs to detect super spreaders, those seemingly healthy people who don’t yet know that they may be infected with the coronavirus. Scientists assert that diseases, such as the flu, have odors and that it is very likely that the coronavirus has a specific odor as well. It is also believed that dogs can detect subtle changes in temperature, opening up the possibility that these dogs can ferret out individuals with fevers. It is their hope that dogs with a highly developed sense of smell would be able to detect the virus at hospitals and nursing homes and eventually, airports and rail stations.

Using canines to sniff out disease is nothing new. Labradors and cocker spaniels are already being used to detect malaria, and dogs have proven able to detect Parkinson’s Disease and some cancers. We’ve already seen the capabilities that canines have: sniffing out bombs, narcotics, weapons, even prohibited fruits, vegetables, and plants, so it’s no wonder that our furry friends can come to our rescue once again and help save lives.

In thanks for all that he does to make you happy and safe, make sure you give Rover an extra belly rub or treat today.

State Law Library and Harris County Law Library Launch Partnership to Expand Digital Services

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

April 29, 2020

Today, the Texas State Law Library and Harris County Law Library announced a new partnership to expand digital services for all Texans. Beginning on Law Day, May 1, 2020, law librarians from both institutions will work together to offer expanded chat services in English and Spanish Monday through Friday. Anyone who needs assistance with legal research can contact a law librarian through either libraries’ website to access expansive collections of digital resources.

“We are excited to expand access to legal information with our partners at the State Law Library,” Harris County Law Library Director Mariann Sears said. “Each library has unique resources to support self-represented litigants, attorneys, and the judiciary. Through this partnership, we can make more of those resources available to help ensure continued access to justice as we stay home and work safe.”

Following guidance from the Supreme Court of Texas and public health officials, both law libraries suspended in-person services in March and expanded virtual services to support remote work by attorneys, judges, and self-represented litigants. Expansion of real-time chat services will further assist the legal community to work remotely following the Supreme Court’s extension of its emergency order through June 1, 2020, allowing Texas courts to postpone hearings and encourage remote participation in proceedings.

“This partnership is a great opportunity for the State Law Library to serve more Texans, especially in Harris County,” Texas State Law Library Assistant Director Amy Small said. “With a third of the Texas legal community and the state’s busiest courts, the Houston metro area has the most potential users of the State Law Library’s expansive digital collections. Working with law librarians at the Harris County Law Library and drawing on their expertise will help us connect more Texans with needed legal resources.”

The new partnership will serve as a pilot program with the goal of expanding opportunities for collaboration between Texas’s network of public law libraries. Law libraries that are interested in participating are encouraged to contact the State Law Library.

About Chat References Services

Law librarians at the Texas State Law Library and Harris County Law Library will offer real-time reference services in English, Spanish, and Farsi, Monday through Friday, from 1:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m., beginning on Friday, May 1, 2020. Visit either library website to access the chat interface and to learn more about digital services.

About the Texas State Law Library

The Texas State Law Library is a public law library that serves the legal research needs of the Texas Supreme Court, the Court of Criminal Appeals, the Office of the Attorney General, other state agencies and commissions, and the citizens of the state. Located in Austin, Texas, the State Law Library offers services and digital collections to all Texans through its website at https://www.sll.texas.gov.

About the Harris County Law Library

The Harris County Law Library opened in 1915 and has continued to serve Harris County’s legal information needs for more than a century. After joining the Office of Vince Ryan, Harris County Attorney, in 2011, the Law Library greatly expanded its technology offerings and services to the public. Today, the Law Library receives more than 60,000 visitors each year, 90% of whom are not lawyers. To learn more about services and digital collections, visit the Harris County Law Library Virtual Reference Desk at https://www.harriscountylawlibrary.org.